How to handle trade-in questions by text
"What's my trade worth?" often comes up in the first few texts. Here's how to answer it honestly, collect what the appraiser needs and leave the number to the person who sees the car.
Texting6 min read
Why customers ask about their trade-in so early
For a lot of buyers, the trade-in is the deal. What they get for their current car decides what they can afford next, so "what's my trade worth?" can arrive before they've asked anything about the car you're selling. Some have already looked up an online estimate and want to know whether you'll match it.
Treat the question as a good sign. A customer asking about their trade-in is working out how the deal would happen, not just browsing. Your job by text is to keep that conversation going without putting a number in writing that the store can't stand behind.
Why you shouldn't quote a trade value by text
A trade value given without seeing the car is a guess. Guess low and the customer feels insulted and texts the next store. Guess high and the number becomes a promise they'll hold you to at the desk, where walking it back costs you the deal and their trust.
Plenty of what decides a trade value never comes up in a text thread: a warning light, a smell, a cracked windshield, uneven tire wear, a past accident, a repainted panel. The person appraising the car needs to see it, drive it and check its history.
It's the same reasoning as answering "what's your best price?" by text: give what's public, and leave the numbers that depend on the deal to the sales manager.
A trade value given without seeing the car is a guess.
How to answer "what's my trade worth?" by text
Say plainly that you won't guess, give the reason in a sentence, and offer the quickest way to a real number. Then ask one question that moves things forward. Lines that work:
- "I'd rather not guess on your trade-in. Our appraiser will give you a real number once they've seen it."
- "If you have an online estimate, bring it along. It's useful to have when our appraiser looks at the car."
- "The quickest way to a real number is a look at the car. Would a weekday evening or Saturday be easier to bring it by?"
What would you give me for my Civic?
Hi Jordan, it's Sam at Northbrook Motors. I'd rather not guess on your Civic, because a number by text is usually wrong one way or the other. Our appraiser will give you a real one after seeing it. Do you know which trim it is?
EX I think. Pretty clean, a few scratches on the back bumper.
Thanks. Could you text me a few photos, including the scratches and the odometer? They give our appraiser a first look.
When the customer pushes for a ballpark
Some customers will ask for "just a rough number". Hold the line politely. A range is still a number: the low end becomes a complaint and the high end becomes a promise. Offer the visit again, and if they won't come in without a figure, pass the request to the sales manager, who decides what to share and how.
What to collect about a trade-in
Ask for the details one at a time, in short texts. A list of questions in one message gets a partial answer and feels like a form. A sensible order:
- 1Year, make and model, and the trim if they know it.
- 2The kilometres or miles on the odometer.
- 3The condition in their own words, including warning lights, damage and anything that needs fixing.
- 4Whether it's been in an accident.
- 5Whether there's a loan or lease on it, and with which lender.
- 6Whether they have both sets of keys.
You don't need every answer before booking a visit. If the customer is ready to come in, book it and collect the rest at the store.
Loans and leases on a trade-in
If there's money owing, the business office will need the lender's name and a payout figure, which US lenders usually call a payoff. Ask by text whether there's a loan, and leave the rest to the business office. Lien paperwork differs by province and by state, so let it run the way your store always does.
Which trade-in photos to ask for
Photos give the appraiser a first look, and they give an interested customer something easy to do. Ask once you have the basics, and say what the photos are for, so they don't read as a way to get a number by text. Ask for:
- The outside, from each corner.
- The odometer with the car running, so any warning lights show.
- The front and back seats.
- The tires, close enough to see the tread.
- Any damage they mentioned, up close.
- The VIN, from the base of the windshield or the driver's door frame.
Tell them how to send the photos. If your texting line accepts pictures, they can reply in the thread. If it doesn't, give them an email address.
For a buyer from out of the area, photos matter even more: they show the appraiser what to look at before the customer makes the drive. Any talk of value after that is still the sales manager's call, by phone or in person rather than by text.
Handing the trade-in to the appraiser
The handoff is where trade-in details get lost. The customer mentions a warning light by text, nobody passes it on, and the appraisal turns into an argument about what was said. Before the visit, make sure the lead has:
- Everything you collected, with condition notes in the customer's own words.
- The photos, attached to the lead rather than sitting in someone's phone.
- Whether there's a loan or lease, and the lender's name.
- Any online estimate the customer mentioned, so it isn't a surprise at the desk.
When you book the visit, tell the customer what to bring: the car, both sets of keys, the ownership and registration papers, and their lender's details if there's money owing. Have a manager approve the visit and check that someone who can appraise the car will be there. We cover approvals in booking more test drives from internet leads.
Clovr Dealr's assistant, Taylor, works inside the same limits. She texts internet leads back within seconds during your texting hours and answers questions about the car with the listed price only, so trade values, discounts, payments and financing stay with your sales manager. She books visits for a manager to approve and hands the lead to a rep. You can see how she handles a conversation on a demo.
Questions dealers ask
Should a salesperson give a trade-in value by text?
No. A value given without seeing the car is a guess, and it either insults the customer or becomes a promise the store can't keep. Collect the details and photos, and let the appraiser give a real number.
What information do you need about a trade-in?
Year, make, model and trim, the kilometres or miles, the condition in the customer's words, any accident history, and whether there's a loan or lease on it.
What photos should a customer send of their trade-in?
The outside from each corner, the odometer with the car running, the seats, the tires, any damage they mentioned and the VIN.
What should a customer bring to a trade-in appraisal?
The car, both sets of keys, the ownership and registration papers, and their lender's details if there's money owing on it.

