How to respond to CarGurus leads: a guide for dealerships
A CarGurus shopper can see your car next to similar ones before they ever message you. Your reply is how they decide whether your store is worth the trip.
Lead response5 min read
What a CarGurus shopper is weighing when they message you
Listing sites make comparing easy. A shopper can look at your car, a similar one across town and another in the next town without getting off the couch. By the time they message you, many have narrowed it down to a few cars and want practical answers. Is it still there? Is the price real? What gets added on top? Is it worth the drive?
Your reply gets judged against the other stores' replies, sometimes on the same evening. The store that answers those questions plainly looks like the easy one to deal with. The store that answers with "When can you come in?" looks like it's hiding something.
The advice here works for stores in Canada and the US. Only the texting rules differ, and we cover them below.
How to respond to a CarGurus lead: the first reply
Keep the first reply short and answer before you ask. Say who you are and which store you're with, confirm the car, answer the question they asked, and end with one easy question.
Is the silver Rogue still for sale? Are there fees on top of the price?
Hi Ben, it's Maya at Northbrook Motors. Yes, it's still here. It's listed at {listed price}, the same as on our website, and taxes and licensing are extra. Are you local, or would you be coming from out of the area?
Local. Is that your best price though?
That's the listed price. Any discount would come from our sales manager, who'd go through the numbers with you in person. Would a weekday evening or Saturday be easier to come see it?
The price question isn't a trap. A shopper comparing listings wants to know whether yours is real and what gets added to it. Answer plainly, and say who handles discounts and payments. There's a full playbook in answering "what's your best price?" by text.
If the customer left a phone number, a text is often the quickest way to answer. Make sure you're allowed to send it first.
What to say when the car is already sold
A car sells in the morning and the listing is still up that night. When a lead comes in on a sold car, say so in the first line. Don't open with a question to keep them talking and break the news a few messages later.
Hi Leah, it's Maya at Northbrook Motors. I'm sorry, the grey Escape sold this morning. We have a blue one with similar equipment, listed at {listed price}. Would you like photos?
Sure, send them over.
Then fix the listing. Every lead on a sold car is a shopper who starts the conversation disappointed. We cover keeping listings accurate in how to respond to AutoTrader leads.
Answering condition and history questions by text
Comparison shoppers ask pointed questions. Has it been in an accident? How are the tires? Is there a warranty? These are fair questions, and a guess is the worst possible answer. A wrong answer by text turns into a problem at delivery.
- History. Share what the vehicle history report on file says, and offer to send it. Don't summarize it from memory.
- Condition. Send photos of exactly what they asked about: the tires, the seats, the scratch on the bumper.
- Warranty and coverage. Don't promise coverage, certification or inspection results unless you've checked the paperwork.
- Anything you don't know. Say you'll find out, then do it, and send the answer before they have to ask again.
Shoppers from out of the area ask more of these questions, because they want to be sure before they make the trip. A walkaround video shot on a phone, narrated plainly, answers a lot of them at once.
Trade-in questions from listing-site shoppers
Many shoppers ask about their trade-in early: "What would you give me for my Civic?" Don't put a number on it by text. A trade value given without seeing the car is either too low and insulting, or too high and a problem at the desk.
Collect what helps the appraiser instead: the year, make and model, the mileage, and a few photos. Then say plainly that the manager gives a real number once they see the car.
Track what happens to your CarGurus leads
The only fair way to judge any lead source is by what happens after the lead reaches your store. If a source's leads rarely turn into visits, look at your replies before you blame the source. Keep the tracking simple:
- Make sure every lead in the CRM carries its source, so CarGurus leads can be pulled on their own.
- Check how long first replies took, both during texting hours and outside them.
- Read a sample of conversations and look for dodged prices, sold cars and guesses.
- Follow each lead to a visit or a sale, not just to a first reply.
If a source's leads rarely turn into visits, look at your replies before you blame the source.
Taylor, the assistant in Clovr Dealr, answers a dealership's internet leads by text along these lines. She answers questions about the car, gives the listed price only, asks whether the customer is local or out of the area, books visits for a manager to approve and hands the lead to a rep. At Parry Sound Chevrolet Buick GMC, 78% of the leads she texted wrote back (Parry Sound case study). You can try her on a demo.
Questions dealers ask
How should a dealership respond to a CarGurus lead?
Say who you are and which store you're with, confirm the car, answer their question and end with one easy question. Give the listed price if they ask, and leave discounts and payments to the sales manager.
What if a CarGurus lead asks about a car that's already sold?
Say so in the first line, then offer a similar car if you have one and be clear it's a different vehicle. Then pull the sold car from every listing.
Should you give a trade-in value to a CarGurus lead by text?
No. Collect the year, make, model, mileage and a few photos, and let the manager give a real number after seeing the car.
How do you know whether your CarGurus leads are working?
Track them by source in your CRM and follow each one to a visit or a sale. If they rarely turn into visits, read your replies before you judge the source.